I've got a situation here in Youngstown with a manufacturing client. During my FirstEnergy audit, I found clear evidence of meter tampering - bypassed current transformers that saved them about $47,000 over 18 months. The plant manager pulled me aside and basically said 'we never saw this, right?' and hinted at more work if I keep quiet. I know what the right answer is, but this is a big client and times are tough. Anyone else dealt with pressure like this? How do you handle it without burning bridges?
Client wants me to ignore obvious meter tampering - ethical dilemma
Jim, you already know the answer. Report it to FirstEnergy immediately and document everything. I had a similar case with ComEd here in Chicago - client threatened to sue me for 'defamation' when I found theft. ComEd's investigators backed me up 100% and the client ended up with criminal charges. Your reputation is worth more than any single client. Plus, if FirstEnergy finds out later that you knew and didn't report, you're looking at potential accessory charges yourself.
Yuri's absolutely right. I've been doing this since the 80s and I've never regretted doing the right thing, even when it cost me business. The CUBA code is crystal clear on this - we have an obligation to report theft. Besides, if word gets out that you'll look the other way for the right price, your credibility is shot forever. Document everything, report it, and find better clients.
Had this exact situation with LG&E in Louisville. Client offered me a $5,000 'bonus' to overlook some creative wiring. I reported it and lost the client, but LG&E started referring other cases to me because they knew I was honest. Sometimes doing the right thing pays off in ways you don't expect. The utility companies talk to each other - they know who the straight shooters are.
Thanks everyone. You're all saying what I already knew I had to do. Called FirstEnergy this morning and filed the report. The client is furious but that's their problem now. I'd rather sleep well at night than compromise my integrity for a few thousand dollars. Appreciate the reality check from you all.
Good for you, Jim. I know it's not easy but you made the right call. APS out here in Phoenix has a zero-tolerance policy and they've prosecuted auditors who failed to report theft. Better to lose one bad client than lose your license and face criminal charges. Your reputation will recover - your integrity wouldn't have.
This is exactly why I always put a clause in my contracts stating that I'm required to report any irregularities to the utility. Sets expectations upfront and protects me legally. PSO here in Tulsa actually requires this language now for any auditor they work with. Covers everyone's backside.
Ed's got a great point about the contract language. I'm adding that to my standard agreement immediately. We Energies up here has been cracking down hard on theft lately - they've got a whole task force dedicated to it. Better to be transparent from day one than deal with this kind of pressure later.