Quick question for the group. I'm reviewing an OG&E account here in Tulsa and their billed demand charges don't seem to match what I'm calculating from the 15-minute interval data. The bill shows 425 kW billing demand but when I analyze the interval data, the highest 15-minute reading for the month was only 387 kW. The customer is on Schedule LMP and getting charged $12.85/kW for demand they apparently didn't use. Anyone know if OG&E has some kind of ratchet provision or minimum demand charge that might explain this discrepancy?
Member Community
Enter your email to read this discussion
You're reading the AAUBA Member Forum — where Certified Utility Bill Auditors share case studies, tariff strategies, and industry insights.
Free to read. Enter your email to continue.
No spam. We'll send you one welcome email about CUBA certification. Unsubscribe any time.
OG&E demand charges not matching interval data totals
Steve, check the OG&E tariff for demand ratchet provisions. A lot of utilities have a clause where your billing demand can't drop below 75% or 80% of the highest demand in the previous 12 months. So even if your actual demand this month was 387 kW, if you hit 500+ kW sometime in the past year, the ratchet might be keeping your billing demand artificially high.
Hank's probably right about the ratchet. We Energies here in Milwaukee has a similar provision where billing demand is the higher of current month actual demand or 65% of the peak demand from the previous summer months. It's designed to recover fixed costs even during low-demand periods. You'll need to look at 12 months of historical data to see if there's a ratchet in effect.