My client in Pennsylvania has been on PPL's Rate Schedule LP-4 for at least 8 years. Just discovered that PPL eliminated LP-4 in their 2019 rate case and migrated everyone to LP-5. But the migration changed the rate structure — LP-4 had a declining block energy charge while LP-5 is a flat rate. My client's high usage meant the declining block was significantly cheaper. They've been overpaying by about $3,200/month since the migration. Is there anything I can do or is this just a legitimate rate increase?
Member Community
Enter your email to read this discussion
You're reading the AAUBA Member Forum — where Certified Utility Bill Auditors share case studies, tariff strategies, and industry insights.
Free to read. Enter your email to continue.
No spam. We'll send you one welcome email about CUBA certification. Unsubscribe any time.
Tariff update just eliminated my client's rate class
When a utility eliminates a rate schedule during a rate case, the PUC approves a transition plan. Check the PUC order for the rate case — it should specify how existing LP-4 customers were supposed to be transitioned. Sometimes there's a grandfathering provision that lets existing customers stay on the old rate structure for a period. Other times there's a transition credit to phase in the increase. If PPL was supposed to provide a transition mechanism and didn't, that's an error in how the rate case order was implemented, not just a rate increase.
Phil is exactly right. Rate case orders almost always include transition provisions when a rate class is eliminated. Pull the PUC order — it's available on the Pennsylvania PUC's docket search. Look for language about "transition," "grandfathering," or "migration credits" for customers moving from LP-4 to LP-5. If the order included a transition credit and PPL didn't apply it, that's a billing error with a potentially large refund. Also check whether LP-5 was truly the most favorable available rate for your client. The rate case may have created a new schedule that would be more advantageous than either the old LP-4 or the new LP-5.
I went through this with a National Grid customer in upstate New York when they eliminated SC-3A. The PUC order included a 3-year phase-in credit that National Grid never applied. Recovered $41,000 for the client. The PUC order is absolutely the document you need.
Found the PUC order. There IS a transition credit for LP-4 to LP-5 customers — a declining credit over 36 months. PPL never applied it. Three years of credits at roughly $2,000/month in the first year declining from there. This is going to be a major recovery. Thank you all.