DTE Energy rolled out smart meters across most of southeast Michigan over the past couple years. My client is a machine shop in Warren, about 150 kW demand. When I compared bills before and after the meter swap in March 2019, the kWh jumped about 15% overnight. Usage patterns had not changed — same equipment, same shifts. Turns out the old mechanical meter had a multiplier of 20 and the new AMI meter was programmed with a multiplier of 24. Nobody at DTE flagged it and the client just assumed rates went up. Six months of overbilling came to about $8,200.
Member Community
Enter your email to read this discussion
You're reading the AAUBA Member Forum — where Certified Utility Bill Auditors share case studies, tariff strategies, and industry insights.
Free to read. Enter your email to continue.
No spam. We'll send you one welcome email about CUBA certification. Unsubscribe any time.
AMI meter rollout changed my client multiplier — nobody told them
This is becoming more common as AMI rollouts continue. The new digital meters sometimes get programmed from a central database rather than from the physical nameplate on the CTs. If there is a data entry error in the database, it propagates to the new meter and nobody does a field verification. I had three of these in the Pittsburgh area with Duquesne Light in 2018.
Oncor in Texas had the same problem during their rollout. I caught four accounts in the DFW area where the multiplier changed during the AMI swap. Two were overbilled, two were underbilled. The underbilled ones I just flagged in the report and moved on — not our problem to solve.
Update — DTE processed the refund in about 6 weeks. They acknowledged the programming error and did not push back at all. My client was happy, I earned a nice fee, and now I have a new checklist item for every audit: check for AMI swap date and compare before/after billing.
This thread is gold. Just starting out and I would never have thought to check for meter swaps specifically. Adding it to my audit checklist now.